recipes

How to Bake Yummy Yeast Rolls

I have tried several recipes in my quest to make delicious-melt-in-your-mouth rolls from scratch. They were all utter failures…..until this one! I found this gem in one of those church cookbooks, and even I was not able to mess it up. Hurray! Here is the recipe, and at the bottom of the recipe there is a printable version. Happy baking!

Best Yet Yeast Rolls

Original Recipe by Sara T. Drummond

Ingredients:

2 pks. Dry yeast               

½c warm water                     

2 lg. eggs                      

1 c. warm water                

½c. shortening (I used coconut oil.)

1 c. sugar

2 tsp. salt

4 ½ c. all-purpose flour

Soft butter

Directions:

Dissolve yeast in ½cup warm water. Let stand 10 minutes.

After 10 minutes, it will look something like this.

Beat eggs and add to the eggs the following: dissolved yeast, 1 cup warm water, shortening, sugar, and salt.

Beat until smooth on medium speed of mixer for about 2 minutes. With a wooden spoon, scrape down sides of the bowl.

Beat in ½of the flour to make a soft dough, using mixer. Add the rest of the flour with wooden spoon to make a soft dough.

Cover and let rise to double in volume, about 1 hour.

Punch down and cover.

Refrigerate overnight.

1/2 of the dough makes a full dozen or so

About 1 ½hours before baking, take out the desired amount. Knead on floured cloth or parchment paper for about 10 minutes, then roll ½inch thick and cut out rolls with cutter. 

I spray my rolling pin with Pam.
Basically rolled out like this, as you can see it doesn’t have to look immaculate.

Place on greased cookie sheet. Let rise until double in size. Bake at 400 for 12-15 minutes or until brown.

12 beautiful, delicious rolls
Quick, easy way to add butter to the tops fresh out of the oven

I personally like to print the recipes, with no photos between, so click here for the printable recipe.

aprilmomoffour

April is an upbeat, Christian, blog-obsessed, military wife, and home schooling mom of four little boys. She writes about education, travel, and humorous adventures in parenting. Follow along if you’d like a little bit of encouragement and a whole lot of crazy.

View Comments

  • Yum! I am sneaky and use Rhodes rolls, but maybe I should try making them myself now that I have your awesome recipe?!

    • I’m usually sneaky too and use Sister Shubert’s rolls, but when there is time it’s nice to make them from scratch.

Share
Published by
aprilmomoffour

Recent Posts

Visiting Stirling Castle was My Favorite Day in the UK

As all good stories should go, I have saved the best for last! Our day…

3 weeks ago

Ancient Roman Vindolanda & the Hunt for Hadrian’s Wall

I'd asked around and learned there were good places to see Hadrian's Wall near the…

4 weeks ago

Adventures in Historical York: Vikings, a Castle, and Wizard Golf

With only a few days in England, I chose York for several reasons: Rick Steeves…

1 month ago

Once in a Lifetime Family Road Trip to York, Our Favorite English City

This family vacation to the United Kingdom was extra special to me because I feel…

2 months ago

Stonehenge & the Night We May Never Forget

On our third day in England, we enjoyed one last free breakfast at the Doubletree…

3 months ago

Hoofing Up to the Prime Meridian Site in Greenwich

Royal Observatory, overlooking the Thames River. Home to the Prime Meridian On day two in…

3 months ago